04 June 2009 @ 10:22 am
NOT to be
I just came across a piece of news on a Twilight com about how the director of Twilight wants to do a Hamlet film and said: "You will understand everything without having a copy of Shakespeare for Dummies with you."

I'm not sure what's more irritating. The fact that she thinks "Hey, I've done Twilight, now I'm totally qualified to direct Shakespeare!" or that she thinks the target audience of her movie will be people who are obviously too stupid to understand Shakespeare.
what: Arcade Fire
how: irritated
location: next to a cup of coffee
( Post a new comment )
moontyger: Arwen reading[personal profile] moontyger on June 4th, 2009 - 09:41 am
And yet, sadly, she might be right. Way back when, some friends of mine and I went to see A Midsummer Night's Dream and, well, from audience reaction, it was clear that we were pretty much the only people in the theater not having trouble with the Elizabethan English. (Ok, ok, maybe they just didn't find it funny, though I fail to see why not.)

OTOH, it's Hamlet and it isn't as though there haven't been several movie versions of it already (and I suspect the story may be better known than the other play). So I very much doubt that it would be a problem.

And I'm not that impressed with the implication that Shakespeare is this inherently complex thing that "normal" people can't understand without a guidebook; I find that mischaracterization as offensive in regard to his work as it is directed at the audience. It's that kind of attitude that leads to people not even trying to read it (or watch it performed) and that's a shame.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
charon[personal profile] charon on June 6th, 2009 - 12:02 pm
Yeah, I will never be able to understand the whole "aim low" mentality. People think something is complicated and they don't even give it a try because of that.

Like, I recently read a book about physics, which was recommended to me by a friend because of its userfriendlyness (for non physicians) and another friend saw that and said "I would never read that, it's way too complicated ...".

But shouldn't something that looks complicated be a challenge? Shouldn't it make you want to read it to prove to yourself that it is possible to read and understand it? Wouldn't that make you feel much better about yourself? Or maybe I'm just weird *lol*
(Reply) (Parent) (Link)